Since Rodney Eade took over as coach for the 1996 season, Sydney has
only missed the finals on three occasions – 2000, 2002 and 2009. No other club
can boast such an impressive record over the same period (West Coast is second
best having only missed the top eight on five occasions).
The Swans hierarchy knows that bottoming-out and rebuilding
isn’t an option that their fans, sponsors and the media in this fickle market
will take kindly too, so they’ve constantly looked outside the box to see who
could thrive on the field to keep the club off the field afloat.
Rather than relying on teenagers chosen in the draft,
picking up players from other clubs and taking them to another level has become
the Swans trademark, and has been the winning formula of keeping them in the
finals.
While the likes of Adam Goodes, Brett Kirk, Jude Bolton,
Michael O’Loughlin and Paul Kelly have all worn red and white their whole
careers, Lockett, Hall, Jolly, Williams and Kennedy have all come from other
clubs and shone.
So how do they compare? On the Swans trash to treasure list,
who ranks as number one?
10. Ted Richards: He joined the club for the 2006 season
from Essendon and took a few years to find his feet but stepped up when Craig
Bolton retired on the eve of the 2011 season. Like Bolton, Richards has the
ability to play on a variety of opponents, and has been in career best form
this season, consistently opting to take saving marks in his own defensive 50
rather than spoiling. He beat Nick Riewoldt comprehensively twice last year and
in round five this year kept Buddy Franklin to just three behinds for the
match. Interestingly, both Sam Lonergan and Courtnay Dempsey who Essendon
picked up in the swap are shining for the resurgent Bombers.
9. Marty Mattner: He’s
the quietly spoken but ever reliable performer in the Swans back six. Mattner
joined the Swans at the end of 2007 after 98 games for Adelaide and has only
missed one game in those five seasons in Sydney. At this rate he’ll play his 200 thAFL game in
round nine against St Kilda, and may for one of the rare occasions speak to the
media.
8. Rhyce Shaw – the
son of former Collingwood captain Ray never felt comfortable with the eyes of
the football world glaring at him at the Magpies. Now in his fourth season at
the Swans, Shaw has taken his game to another level with his run and rebound
out of the back 50 and has been rewarded with finishing runner-up twice in the
Club Champion award in his time in Red and White. Shaw has been challenged
again this season playing as a defensive half forward as well as having some
tough tagging roles on Brent Harvey and Cyril Rioli.
7. Shane Mumford –
The Boy from Bunyip would clearly be the number one ruckman at his former club
Geelong (where he played 21 games) this season with Brad Ottens retired, but
instead he may get his opportunity to lead a young Swans line-up to Grand Final
glory. A string of back injuries have meant a frustrating 2012 for Mumford, but
when he returns, he’s sure to bounce back as one of the games best ruckmen with a strong presence at
ground level. Mumford is not even 25 years old yet, meaning his best rucking
years are probably still ahead of him. Geelong have also done well out of this
deal with Mitch Duncan (pick 28 in 2009 draft) now a regular in the Cats line
up.
6. Darren Jolly –
Now leading the Collingwood ruck division, but was also the spearhead of the
Swans midfield for five years, and played a starring role in the 2005 Grand
Final win. The Swans picked up Jolly from the Demons in exchange for draft pick
15 (Lynden Dunn), and he only missed two games in his five years at the club.
Sydney had to part ways with him when he requested a trade back to his native
Victoria for he and his young family ahead of the 2010 season. The trade saw
the Swans get pick 14 in the draft, opening the way for excitement machine
Lewis Jetta to join the club. Jolly has gone on to win another flag at
Collingwood.
5. Craig Bolton – By
his own admission, Craig Bolton was at the cross roads when he joined the Swans
for the 2003 season. He’d been on the list of competition heavy weights
Brisbane for three years but failed to fill a regular spot and only managed 29
games for the Lions. His ability to play on both tall and small forwards led to
two All Australian jerseys and in 2005, Bolton was part of the premiership side
he so thoroughly deserved. Unfortunately, an ankle injury brought a premature
end to his career, leaving the popular ACT product stranded on 199 AFL games.
4. Paul Williams – I
bet you forgot about him. After a staggering 189 games for Collingwood,
Williams headed north at the end of 2000 and slotted straight into the Swans
midfield. He went on to play a further117 games at the Swans and is another
member of the 2005 premiership side. When he and his team mates lifted the Cup
in September 2005, Williams set the record for the most VFL/AFL matches played
before winning a Grand Final. Hawk Shane Crawford broke that record three years
later. The man affectionately known as Wilo won back-to-back Club
Championships at the Swans with his hard running, pace and booming right boot
being a huge asset to the Swans. Williams is still in the AFL system, currently
as an assistant coach at Carlton after stints at Melbourne and Western
Bulldogs.
3. Josh Kennedy –
after playing just 13 games for the club his Father and Grandfather are legends
of, Hawthorn showed Kennedy the door. He was considered surplus to requirements
in a midfield boasting Brad Sewell, Luke Hodge and Sam Mitchell. The Swans
swooped with pick 39 in the 2009 draft and since then, Kennedy has forged
himself a reputation as one of the competitions best inside midfielders; he’s
had the seventh most possessions in the AFL this year, and leads the way in
contested possessions (103) and hard ball gets (45). Many believe Kennedy would
be currently leading the Brownlow medal count, and most betting agencies have
brought him in from 500/1 to the third line of betting at around $8. The
23-year-old, who is under club orders to lay off the weights, is also one of
the best midfield marks in the competition with an ability above his head
similar to Jimmy Bartel. A premiership with the Swans could take Kennedy to the
top of this list. I wonder if Hawthorn is regretting its decision yet?
2. Tony Lockett - Like
the song says, “There’s only one Tony Lockett.” The song doesn’t say much else,
but it still makes its point. Lockett pulled the Swans out of the doldrums and
into the 1996 Grand Final and topped the list of greatest goal kickers of all
time while at the club. Plugger was traded north after 183 games and 898 goals
at St Kilda, for Robert Neill and the number five draft pick used to grab Joel
Smith. Yep, it’s pretty clear who did the better out of that deal. Lockett had
grown tired of the media spotlight of being a star footballer in Melbourne, and
a more low profile life in Sydney was ideal. Another 98 goals, two more Coleman
Medals as the leading goal kicker for the season (he also won two at the
Saints) and the final three of his five All Australian jerseys all occurred in
his time in the Harbour City.
1. Barry Hall
- Before you
jump up and down and start comparing Hall to Lockett and abuse me for putting
Big Bad Bustling Barry above Plugger, think about the premise of this list –
trash to treasure, the best trades ever done by the Swans. My reason for the
order is that on that final Saturday in September, 2005, when the Swans broke
their Premiership drought, it was Barry Hall that held the Cup aloft – a feat
Plugger never managed. After six years at the Saints, Hall was also struggling
under the harsh media spotlight of Melbourne, and found solace in the relative
anonymity of Sydney. His former club did well out of the trade too, using the
number 13 pick to grab 200 gamer Nick Dal Santo. Hall went on to be named an
All Australian player, Swans co-captain, leading goal kicker seven years in a
row and Club Champion (2004). A number of violent on field episodes, injuries
and a fall out with coach Paul Roos led to Hall joining the Bulldogs at the end
of 2009, but if premierships are what we play this great game for, then in my
eyes Barry has to be number one on the list.